DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

Last Updated on May 7, 2021

Most of us have a nice nativity sitting on our mantles. Or as my husband would say, I have several. OOPS! Many people wouldn’t even think about letting our kids play with them. I do though, somehow my kids add dinosaurs, ninja turtles, and more at times to my display. However, I found when they were really small, having their own nativity set to play with was such a great idea. That is why I love these DIY felt nativity finger puppets that my kids can play with and reenact Bible stories. 

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

I love this time of year and what it symbolizes. Setting up all my nativities and admiring them makes me happy.  It’s the story of Christ and the heart of why we celebrate Christmas at my house. I wanted my children to embrace and explore the true meaning of Christmas with a nativity they could safely handle and play with every day. Needless to say, I was thrilled when I found this DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppet project. 

***Keep Scrolling for a Giveaway***


Make Your Own DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

I’ve wanted to make a nativity set my kids could play with throughout the holiday season. There are plenty of nativity set toys to buy, but I wanted something durable and different. This felt set fit the bill plus it’s soft and fun to play with. Plus, I can make it with my kids and we can discuss the Biblical story of the nativity and the miracle of Christ. That’s what Christmas is about.

I know there are several types of nativity sets out there and many ways to make one as a craft. This one is nice because it is attractive and easy to make with the kids, and inexpensive too. 

Do I have to use hot glue?

I chose the hot glue gun because it’s easy to use and, personally, saves time. You can choose fabric glue if you like. You can also stitch the pieces together, but that will add time and make the project take quite a bit longer.

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets


How long does it take to do the craft project?

The longest part of making these DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets is cutting them out. It’s going to take an hour or two. I set aside an afternoon to make them with my kids.


How do you use the felt finger puppets?

I let my kids act as the quality control agents with the finger puppets. They’ve used them to retell the Christmas story many times over. Sometimes, I play with them and tell the story to them again. Kids are creative, and while the main goal is focused on the true meaning of Christmas, kids will find plenty of ways to create elaborate stories with the finger puppets.


What You Will Need to make DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

Here are the materials you will need for this project:

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

  • Felt sheets or felt scraps in 10 different colors (light blue, blue, white, gold, yellow, brown, camel, forest green, purple, maroon, and flesh)
  • Fabric scissors
  • Printable nativity finger puppet pattern ***See Below***
  • Hot Glue Gun and clear glue sticks
  • Paint pen in black


Directions for Making DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

Gather all the materials and supplies listed. 

Choose 10 different colors of felt sheets as listed above. You will only need a small amount of felt for each finger puppet, so it’s okay to use pieces or scraps.


Preparation and Cutting

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

Print off the nativity finger puppet pattern on 8.5 x 11 sheets of paper.

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets


Working on one puppet at a time, cut loosely around each of the individual pattern pieces.

Place the pattern piece over the felt sheet and cut the felt pieces out along the solid line.

Cut out each piece in the desired color of felt. 

Continue cutting out the other finger puppet patterns.

Assembling the Pieces

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

Using the printed template as a guide, paint the eyes and the mouth on the felt face pieces using the black paint pen.

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

Preheat the glue gun.

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

You will need to work quickly since hot glue dries quickly. Apply a bead of glue along the outer edge of the felt body piece as shown. Leave the bottom edge without any glue.

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

While the glue is hot and soft, press the matching felt bogy piece on top.

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets


DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

Next, glue the remaining felt piece on top. (This includes the face, hands, hair, etc.)

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

For the angel puppet, glue the halo to one of the body pieces before gluing the body pieces together. This will sandwich the halo in between the two body parts.

Similarly, for the baby Jesus puppet, glue the straw piece on one of the body pieces before gluing the body pieces together. You want to sandwich the straw in between.

Continue assembling the finger puppets in the same manner until they are all complete.


What if I don’t have the right colors of felt?

Feel free to substitute or switch out colors for what you do have on hand. That’s one of the neatest things about this project is it is flexible and inexpensive. 

DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets

This is a fun project to do leading up to the Christmas holiday. I like it for a lot of reasons. For one, I love reiterating the story of the gift of Christ to the world. Secondly, it’s a fun project to do with my kids during the holiday season. Thirdly, it’s not over after the DIY Felt Nativity Finger Puppets are made. That’s when the fun really begins!

Don’t forget to print out the craft for later!

Air Fryer Fried Tortellini

Air Fryer Fried Tortellini


Freezer Bag Instructions

1) Score the top of the tenderloin a few times. This will allow the meat to marinade better and release excess fat while cooking.

2) Place the pork tenderloin in a freezer bag.

3) Cover the tenderloin with the remaining ingredients.

4) Seal the freezer bag and remove any excess air. Shake up the bag so that the marinade is mixed. Write the cooking instructions on the bag then roll it in half and place the tenderloin in the freezer for up to 1 month.

Cooking Label: Honey Soy Tenderloin 75 Minutes or 1:15 (25 minutes per lb.)

NPR Cooking Directions from frozen:

1) Defrost the tenderloin enough to be able to remove it from the bag.

2) Place the tenderloin and all the marinade in the Instant Pot. Scored side up. Do not set it on a trivet or add any extra liquid. The marinade is enough liquid to bring it pressure as it defrosts.

3) Close the lid and turn the pressure valve to sealing. Cook the tenderloin on high pressure for 75 minutes or 1 hour 15 minutes using the "Meat/Stew", "Manual", or "Pressure Cook" options. Let the pressure naturally release.

4) Check the internal temperature to make sure it reaches 170 degrees then remove the tenderloin. Set it aside to rest for at least 10 minutes before slicing. If the internal temperature hasn't reached 170 then let it cook for another 10 minutes.

5) While the tenderloin is resting, simmer the juice left in the Instant Pot on sauté mode to make a glaze. Let the juice simmer for 10-15 minutes until it has reduced and thickened. Then spoon it over the tenderloin and serve.


Disclaimer: I have inputted all ingredients into a program. I am not a nutritionist or dietician. So I cannot be held responsible for the validity of these calculations. ~Laura

Well, 2020 has been quite a year. It’s definitely been one for the books and one we will likely never forget. We have made it to the holiday season – a time for gratitude, togetherness, and celebration. And to celebrate the holiday season and the year 2020 coming to an end, I’ve teamed up with some of my favorite bloggers for the 7th annual Christmas Blessings Giveaway with the hopes of making this holiday season even more memorable (in a good way) for TWO families by giving away $500 in Paypal cash to each family.

While we wish we could bless many more families, we were able to come up with a big prize for TWO families – $500 each (delivered via Paypal) – that we pray will make a big difference in their lives this Christmas season – whether it’s to fulfill their kids’ Christmas wishes, pay off some bills, or to help build some savings, our prayer is that it helps to lessen any financial burden and/or fills a specific need, or simply brightens your day.

There are lots of entry options in the Rafflecopter form below – the more you enter, the better your chance of winning! I know it can seem tedious and time-consuming to go through all the entries, but isn’t a chance at $500 worth it? I think it is! Plus, all of these amazing bloggers donated their own money toward the cash prizes, so this giveaway wouldn’t be possible without them. I hope you’ll take the time to check out each one. Who knows, maybe you will find some new blogs to follow.

The giveaway will run from Monday, November 16th through Wednesday, November 25th (ends at 11:59 pm EST). The winner will be notified by email shortly after the giveaway ends and will have 48 hours to respond to claim the prize or another winner will be drawn. You must have a Paypal account to win. By entering this giveaway, you agree to be added to the email lists of the participating bloggers. Please be sure to read the Rafflecopter terms and conditions upon entering.

a Rafflecopter giveaway


Leave a Comment

Halfway Homesteaders Skip to Instructions